Free PDF Ibn 'Arabi in the Later Islamic Tradition: The Making of a Polemical Image in Medieval Islam (Suny Series in Islam) (Suny Series, Islam)
Yeah, reading a publication Ibn 'Arabi In The Later Islamic Tradition: The Making Of A Polemical Image In Medieval Islam (Suny Series In Islam) (Suny Series, Islam) could include your friends lists. This is just one of the solutions for you to be effective. As understood, success does not suggest that you have fantastic points. Comprehending as well as understanding greater than other will give each success. Beside, the notification as well as impression of this Ibn 'Arabi In The Later Islamic Tradition: The Making Of A Polemical Image In Medieval Islam (Suny Series In Islam) (Suny Series, Islam) could be taken and also picked to act.
Ibn 'Arabi in the Later Islamic Tradition: The Making of a Polemical Image in Medieval Islam (Suny Series in Islam) (Suny Series, Islam)
Free PDF Ibn 'Arabi in the Later Islamic Tradition: The Making of a Polemical Image in Medieval Islam (Suny Series in Islam) (Suny Series, Islam)
Ibn 'Arabi In The Later Islamic Tradition: The Making Of A Polemical Image In Medieval Islam (Suny Series In Islam) (Suny Series, Islam). Modification your habit to hang or lose the moment to only talk with your pals. It is done by your everyday, do not you feel burnt out? Currently, we will reveal you the new behavior that, really it's a very old routine to do that can make your life more certified. When really feeling burnt out of consistently chatting with your pals all spare time, you could locate the book qualify Ibn 'Arabi In The Later Islamic Tradition: The Making Of A Polemical Image In Medieval Islam (Suny Series In Islam) (Suny Series, Islam) then review it.
There is no question that book Ibn 'Arabi In The Later Islamic Tradition: The Making Of A Polemical Image In Medieval Islam (Suny Series In Islam) (Suny Series, Islam) will certainly consistently give you inspirations. Even this is merely a book Ibn 'Arabi In The Later Islamic Tradition: The Making Of A Polemical Image In Medieval Islam (Suny Series In Islam) (Suny Series, Islam); you could find many categories and kinds of publications. From captivating to journey to politic, and also sciences are all offered. As just what we specify, here our company offer those all, from well-known writers as well as author in the world. This Ibn 'Arabi In The Later Islamic Tradition: The Making Of A Polemical Image In Medieval Islam (Suny Series In Islam) (Suny Series, Islam) is among the compilations. Are you interested? Take it currently. Just how is the method? Find out more this write-up!
When someone must go to guide establishments, search store by store, shelf by rack, it is really problematic. This is why we supply the book collections in this internet site. It will certainly ease you to search the book Ibn 'Arabi In The Later Islamic Tradition: The Making Of A Polemical Image In Medieval Islam (Suny Series In Islam) (Suny Series, Islam) as you like. By browsing the title, publisher, or authors of the book you really want, you could locate them swiftly. At home, workplace, or perhaps in your means can be all best place within internet connections. If you intend to download and install the Ibn 'Arabi In The Later Islamic Tradition: The Making Of A Polemical Image In Medieval Islam (Suny Series In Islam) (Suny Series, Islam), it is really simple then, since currently we extend the connect to buy and also make offers to download Ibn 'Arabi In The Later Islamic Tradition: The Making Of A Polemical Image In Medieval Islam (Suny Series In Islam) (Suny Series, Islam) So very easy!
Curious? Of course, this is why, we suppose you to click the web link web page to go to, and then you can delight in the book Ibn 'Arabi In The Later Islamic Tradition: The Making Of A Polemical Image In Medieval Islam (Suny Series In Islam) (Suny Series, Islam) downloaded up until completed. You could save the soft data of this Ibn 'Arabi In The Later Islamic Tradition: The Making Of A Polemical Image In Medieval Islam (Suny Series In Islam) (Suny Series, Islam) in your gadget. Of course, you will bring the gadget anywhere, won't you? This is why, every time you have spare time, each time you could enjoy reading by soft copy publication Ibn 'Arabi In The Later Islamic Tradition: The Making Of A Polemical Image In Medieval Islam (Suny Series In Islam) (Suny Series, Islam)
This book examines the fierce theological controversy over the great Muslim mystical thinker Ibn 'Arabi (1165-1242). Even during his lifetime, Ibn 'Arabi's conformity with the letter of the Muslim dogma was called into doubt by many scholars who were suspicious of the monistic (unitive) tendencies of his metaphysical teaching, of his claims to be the Prophet's successor and restorer of the true meaning of the Islamic revelation, and of his allegorical interpretation of the Qur'an. In thoroughly analyzing the heated debates around Ibn 'Arabi's ideas throughout the three centuries following his death, this study brings out discursive strategies and arguments employed by the polemicists, the hidden agendas they pursued, and the reasons for the striking longevity of the issue in Islamic literature up to the present day. On the theoretical level, this book reassesses the validity of such common dichotomies as orthodoxy versus heresy, mainstream versus mystical interpretations of Islam, and communalism versus individualism as well as other issues related to the history of Islamic thought.
- Sales Rank: #1483146 in Books
- Color: Blue
- Published on: 1998-12-23
- Original language: English
- Number of items: 1
- Dimensions: 9.00" h x 1.05" w x 6.00" l, 1.33 pounds
- Binding: Paperback
- 466 pages
Review
"Knysh has looked at exactly who were the supporters and opponents of Ibn 'Arabi for several centuries after his death, where they were getting their information, why they should have taken the position they took, and so forth. The author brings together a lot of tidbits in the secondary literature that people have not connected, and he does so with careful attention to the primary texts." -- William C. Chittick, author of The Self Disclosure of God: Principles of Ibn 'Arabi's Cosmology
About the Author
Alexander D. Knysh is The Sharjah Professor of Islamic Studies, Department of Arabic and Middle East Studies, University of Exeter, United Kingdom.
Most helpful customer reviews
13 of 13 people found the following review helpful.
The Great Sheykh and his detractors
By Linas Kondratas
The book of A.D. Knysh is an excellent reader for those who are interested not only in the personality of Ibn Arabi himself or his ideas, but also in the reception of these ideas by the medieval Muslim society (second half of XIII to XV centuries) in the framework of which Ibn Arabi lived. The author takes completely impartial, scholarly position without leaning for or against the Great Sheykh. The author limits himself to Arab speaking regions (Egypt and Syria, Maghreb and Yemen) This reception as it appears was far from unanimous and produced a heated polemics which started just two decades after Great Sheykh's death. The detractors of Ibn Arabi who were more numerous than supporters subjected Ibn Arabi's work to rigorous criticism and very often outright condemnation. One of the driving forces behind the criticism was the care of the Islamic scholars about the interest of the community and their apprehension that Ibn Arabi's monistic worldview blurring the distinction between God and the world, and the idea about the invisible hierarchy of saints etc. can make prejudice to the beliefs, morality and social order of the Islamic ummah. The struggle for the ideas of Ibn Arabi was not always disinterested struggle on dogmatic matters, it was often related with the vying for quite "earthly" things such as official positions, power and social prestige. Quite often the deabate was quite dangerous and fraught with serious consequences for those involved in it. A.Knysh shows that the detractors of Ibn Arabi were not completely able to comprehend the entire sophistication of Great Sheykh's style and ideas. Yet, to his opinion, they were able comprehend the key issues of his teaching especially those which can ideological or social relevance to broad masses of the believers. However the usual taxonomic schema used by medieval authors to classify the figures of the Islamic thought(specialist of hadith, jurist, theologian, mystic) has appeared inappropriate to fully comprehend the sophisticated teachings of the Great Sheykh which defied all the attempts of classification( extreme literalism and thorough going exotericism both present in the works of Ibn Arabi). Besides that under the main themes in Ibn Arabi's became settled there were little attempt to cast a fresh into the Sheykh's work. The detractors, as well as the supporters, are shown to be not limited to any particular school or sect, rather the line between being pro- or against Ibn Arabi runs across various schools. The author shows that being anti Ibn Arabi by far was not equivalent with being anti Sufi, and that the absolute majority of the detractors were in one or other form affiliated with Sufism or exposed to its ideas. A.Knysh equally questions the usual assumption about the struggle between " "Theologians" with "Sufis" showing that most of the participants of the debate were all the three, and that the debate was the encounter between the various standpoints in both theology and Sufism. A. Knysh also questions the usual assumption when Islam is presented as an "orthoprax" religion where dogmatic difference are not so important when the requirements of ritual decorum are satisfied. The heated debated on the doctrinal issues concerning the "unity of being" clearly show the opposite. While describing the reception of Ibn Arabi's ideas in the Western part of the Islamic world the author shows that differently from the Eastern lands of Islam, Ibn Arabi was not considered here such paramount figure or founder of the monistic school, but rather as a representative of the broader tradition or "plot" of monists, and Ibn Sab`in, another monistic Sufi from Maghreb was considered of equal importance to Ibn Arabi, if not greater. A.Knysh devotes separate chapters or parts of them to some of more known detractors of Ibn Arabi such as Syrian Shafi`i scholar Izz al-Din Abd al-Salam who as the first detractor and contemporary of Ibn Arabi had great importance to later makers of the polemic image, to well-know Hanbali Ibn Taimiyya, and to Hanafite al-Taftazani. In the chapter devoted to Maghreb he analyses three specific personalities, one of them being the famous Ibn Khaldoon. Chapters are also devoted to the reception of Ibn Arabi's ideas in Mamlook kingdom of Egypt and Syria, and in Yemen. Since the Islamic life of Yemen is relatively little known, and A.Knysh is one of the leading experts on Yemeni Islam, this chapter of his book is especially interesting and instructive.
1 of 2 people found the following review helpful.
A classic debate in Medieval Islam
By Rumi Fan
This is an incredible piece of scholarship. Professor Knysh, a Russian scholar of Islam, demonstrates his mastery of the vast literature of Islam in various languages including Arabic, Turkish, German, French, and Russian. This is the first major account of the intellectual battles raging on in the Middle East between two opposing giants: the school of Ibn Arabi and the school of Ibn Taymiyya. However, to be fair, it is mostly concerned with the scholarly attacks led by Ibn Taymiyya against the doctrine of wahdat al-wujud of Ibn Arabi. What makes this account so fascinating is the survey of the political and intellectual environment of Medieval Damascus, and Egypt.
It is clear from Professor Knysh's analysis how important the ulama and Islamic religious institutions were for Muslim Sultans, rulers, and princes. In particular, it highlights the intricate, and complex relationship between the Mamluk state and the religious scholars of Islam. The 13th century was a watershed moment in Islamic political history with the Mongol devastation in the central Muslim lands and the continuous Christian Crusades into the Levant. While it seemed that Muslim civilization was on the brink of collapse from these two assaults, along come the Mamluks of Damascus and Egypt who boldly stopped the Mongol advance in Palestine in the famous battle of Ayn Jalut, near present day Galilea. The role of the stalwart Mamluks in well known to peole of the Middle East. However, what is often overlook in the patronage and funding that the Mamluks provided to Islamic learning and to Islamic scholars. This is witnessed by the huge number of sufi lodges and madrasas supported and funded by Mamluk princes and rulers. Scholars such as Ibn Taymiyya, Ibn Arabi, al-Dhahabi, and Ibn Atallah were some of the major scholars who owed their support to the Mamluk rulers of that time, though the relationship with Ibn Taymiyya is complicated by the persecution he faced by his opponents.
Knyshs' contribution to this important time period is to lay out a narrative which demonstrates the critique of some of the theological views of Ibn Arabi by Ibn Taymiyya and his ideological supporters. He traces how the critique developed and who the central partisans were. It is clear from Professor Knysh's analysis that Ibn Taymiyya was not anti-tasawwuf or sufism. Many opponents of tasawwuf today use Ibn Taymiyya as a sword in discrediting sufism and undermining its legitimacy in Islam. However, this view is misplaced given that Ibn Taymiyya commended many aspects of sufi practice and also praised many sufi leaders and thinkers. Ibn Taymiyya's main problem was the central cosmological worldview of Ibn Arabi's wahdat al-wujud which is often referred to Islamic "monism." This view essentially argues that God is the only true reality while everything thing else he creates is temporary and unreal.
The footnotes are useful and comprehensive but often hinder the narrative of the story. But this is to be expected in a scholarly work. This book is not for novices but for those who are acquainted with the Islamic scholarly and intellectual tradition.
Ibn 'Arabi in the Later Islamic Tradition: The Making of a Polemical Image in Medieval Islam (Suny Series in Islam) (Suny Series, Islam) PDF
Ibn 'Arabi in the Later Islamic Tradition: The Making of a Polemical Image in Medieval Islam (Suny Series in Islam) (Suny Series, Islam) EPub
Ibn 'Arabi in the Later Islamic Tradition: The Making of a Polemical Image in Medieval Islam (Suny Series in Islam) (Suny Series, Islam) Doc
Ibn 'Arabi in the Later Islamic Tradition: The Making of a Polemical Image in Medieval Islam (Suny Series in Islam) (Suny Series, Islam) iBooks
Ibn 'Arabi in the Later Islamic Tradition: The Making of a Polemical Image in Medieval Islam (Suny Series in Islam) (Suny Series, Islam) rtf
Ibn 'Arabi in the Later Islamic Tradition: The Making of a Polemical Image in Medieval Islam (Suny Series in Islam) (Suny Series, Islam) Mobipocket
Ibn 'Arabi in the Later Islamic Tradition: The Making of a Polemical Image in Medieval Islam (Suny Series in Islam) (Suny Series, Islam) Kindle
Tidak ada komentar:
Posting Komentar